Category: Cruise Planning

When I first started looking at Alaska cruises, I thought choosing one would mostly come down to finding the right cruise line, ship and dates.

Then I started comparing itineraries.

One of the biggest decisions isn’t which ship to sail on at all. It’s whether to take a roundtrip cruise from Seattle or Vancouver or a one-way cruise between Vancouver and Alaska.

Both can give you an incredible Alaska experience, but the logistics are very different. I’ve sailed to Alaska roundtrip from Seattle twice, but this time we’re doing something different: a one-way cruise from Vancouver to Alaska.

Planning this trip has made me realize how many additional decisions come with a one-way itinerary and, if I were starting over, there are a few things I would consider much earlier in the process.

Roundtrip or One-Way: What’s the Difference?

A roundtrip Alaska cruise begins and ends in the same city. Seattle and Vancouver are the two departure ports you’ll see most often, and these itineraries are usually seven nights.

A one-way cruise travels between Vancouver and Alaska. You can sail northbound from Vancouver to Whittier or Seward or reverse the trip and sail southbound from Whittier or Seward to Vancouver.

That distinction may not seem particularly important when you’re looking at the cruise itself. But it can make a big difference when you start planning the rest of the trip.

Why Choose a Roundtrip Alaska Cruise?

For pure convenience, roundtrip cruises have a lot going for them.

You fly into one city, board your cruise and return to the same city a week later. That makes airfare much easier to shop because you’re looking for a traditional roundtrip ticket instead of coordinating flights from two different places.

Seattle can be particularly convenient for U.S. travelers because there are so many domestic flight options. Vancouver requires an international flight or another way of getting into Canada, but it is also a popular starting point for Alaska cruises.

If your primary goal is to experience Alaska by cruise and then head home, a roundtrip itinerary can be the simplest choice. But don’t choose one based on convenience alone. The actual route still matters, including where the ship sails, which glaciers it visits and how much time you have in each port.

We’ll dig much deeper into those differences in another article.

Why Choose a One-Way Alaska Cruise?

A one-way cruise can be a great option if you want to see more of Alaska or simply prefer the itinerary it offers. Instead of returning to your original departure port, you’ll sail between Vancouver and Alaska, with most itineraries beginning or ending in Whittier or Seward.

For travelers who want to add Denali or another inland Alaska experience, a one-way cruise makes that especially easy. You can cruise north from Vancouver and continue exploring Alaska afterward or do the land portion first and then take a southbound cruise to Vancouver.

We’re taking a northbound cruise from Vancouver on this trip, although we’re not adding a land tour afterward. When we booked, I was primarily focused on the cruise itinerary itself. As I’ve worked through the rest of the travel arrangements, however, I’ve realized there is another option I didn’t fully appreciate when we first started planning: doing the entire route in reverse.

You Can Do the Whole Trip in Reverse

One-way Alaska cruises also sail southbound. You can fly into Alaska first, spend time exploring inland and then board your cruise in Whittier or Seward for the trip south to Vancouver.

We’re traveling with friends who have already done a southbound Alaska cruise but haven’t sailed northbound. Choosing the northbound itinerary gives all of us a chance to experience something new together, which was one of the reasons we chose it.

In hindsight, though, I probably would have given the southbound option more consideration.

Why?

Because getting to your cruise and getting home from your cruise are two separate travel considerations.

With our northbound itinerary, getting to Vancouver has been fairly straightforward. The more challenging piece has been finding a flight home from Anchorage that doesn’t involve an itinerary I really don’t want, particularly an overnight flight.

Had we reversed the trip, we could have handled the flight to Alaska at the beginning of our vacation, cruised south and ended in Vancouver.

Would I change our trip now? No. I’m excited about the way we’ve planned it. But if I were starting from scratch, I would compare the northbound and southbound options before deciding.

A Quick Note About Whittier, Seward and Anchorage

This is an important detail for first-time Alaska cruisers because cruise listings can make the geography a little confusing.

You may see itineraries marketed as traveling to or from Anchorage, but large cruise ships don’t actually depart from Anchorage. Most one-way cruises use Whittier or Seward as their Alaska turnaround port, and you’ll need transportation between the cruise port and Anchorage.

The distance matters, too. Whittier is approximately 60 miles from Anchorage, with a typical motorcoach transfer taking around two hours. Seward is farther south, approximately 125 miles from Anchorage, and the motorcoach trip generally takes about three hours. I looked at Seward itineraries when we were planning our trip, and the additional travel time was one of the logistics I had to consider.

Depending on your cruise, transportation may be available through the cruise line, or you can arrange it yourself. Either way, it’s worth looking at the transfer time and cost when you’re comparing itineraries.

Your cruise may end in “Anchorage” on Saturday morning, for example, but that doesn’t mean you’ll be standing at the Anchorage airport shortly after you walk off the ship. Where your ship actually docks matters when you’re planning the rest of your travel day.

Seattle or Vancouver?

If you’re considering a roundtrip cruise, you’ll likely find plenty of options from both Seattle and Vancouver.

Seattle has an obvious advantage for many U.S. travelers: ease of access. There are often more flight choices, and you don’t have the added international travel considerations of beginning your trip in Canada.

But Vancouver shouldn’t be ruled out simply because Seattle is easier to reach.

Another difference worth considering is the actual sailing route. Many Seattle departures travel along the western side of Vancouver Island, while Vancouver sailings often follow the more sheltered waterways of the Inside Passage. That can mean different scenery and potentially different sea conditions. It’s worth comparing the route maps rather than assuming every Alaska cruise follows the same path.

So rather than asking, “Which departure city is better?” I would ask:

Which departure city gives me the itinerary I want while still making sense for the rest of my trip?

That’s a much more useful question.

Look at the Whole Trip Before You Book the Cruise

This is probably the biggest lesson I’ve learned from planning ours.

It’s very easy to shop for an Alaska cruise as though the vacation begins when you step onto the ship and ends when you step off.

It doesn’t.

Before booking, look at the entire trip.

How will you get to the embarkation port? What does airfare look like? Where will you stay the night before the cruise? If you’re taking a one-way cruise, how will you get between Whittier or Seward and Anchorage? Are you adding Denali or another land experience? And most importantly, how are you getting home?

I would actually search the flights before putting down the cruise deposit. You don’t necessarily need to book airfare that early, but seeing the available routes gives you a much better understanding of the logistics involved.

A cruise that looks perfect on paper may be less appealing once you add complicated flights, transfers and extra hotel nights. On the other hand, those extra logistics may be completely worth it if a one-way cruise allows you to experience more of Alaska.

So, Which Alaska Cruise Should You Choose?

If you want a relatively simple seven-night Alaska vacation, I’d start by looking at roundtrip cruises from Seattle and Vancouver. I’ve sailed roundtrip from Seattle twice, and there is definitely something to be said for the simplicity of flying in and out of the same city.

If you want to add Denali or spend more time exploring Alaska before or after your cruise, a one-way itinerary gives you more flexibility. But a land trip isn’t the only reason to choose one-way. You may simply prefer the itinerary, ports or scenic cruising offered on those sailings.

If you’re considering a one-way cruise, compare both northbound and southbound options before you book. Think about the cruise itinerary, but also consider the flights, transfers and logistics on both ends of the trip.

Neither direction is inherently better. The better choice is the one that works for your entire vacation, including how you’ll get there, where the ship begins or ends and how you’ll get home.

And once you’ve decided between roundtrip and one-way, there’s another question waiting for you: which Alaska itinerary should you actually choose?

Because even when the ports look almost identical, they aren’t necessarily the same cruise.

Thinking About an Alaska Cruise?

Choosing between roundtrip and one-way is just one part of planning an Alaska cruise. I can help you compare itineraries, think through the travel logistics and find the option that fits the way you want to experience Alaska.

Voyage with Amy
Expertly Planned. Personally Crafted.

One of the things that makes cruising appealing is how much of your vacation is bundled into one price. Your accommodations travel with you, meals are readily available and there is usually plenty to do without spending anything extra once you’re onboard. But if you’ve ever started pricing a cruise, you may have discovered that the fare you first see isn’t necessarily what you’ll ultimately spend.

So what does a cruise fare actually include?

The answer varies somewhat depending on which cruise line you choose, but understanding the basics can make comparing cruises much easier and help you build a more realistic vacation budget.

Your Cabin

Your cruise fare includes your accommodations for the duration of your sailing. Whether you choose an inside cabin, oceanview, balcony or suite, that room becomes your home while the ship carries you from one destination to the next.

That’s one of my favorite things about cruising. You can wake up somewhere new without packing your suitcase, checking out of a hotel and figuring out how to get to the next destination.

The cabin category you choose will affect the price of your cruise, sometimes significantly, but the basic accommodations are part of the fare.

Most of Your Meals

You certainly don’t have to pay extra every time you’re hungry on a cruise ship. Most cruise fares include meals in the ship’s main dining rooms as well as a buffet and other complimentary dining options. Depending on the ship, you may also find included casual restaurants, cafés, poolside grills or quick-service spots.

Where it gets a little more complicated is specialty dining.

Many ships also offer restaurants that charge an additional fee. These might include steakhouses, Italian restaurants, sushi, seafood or other specialty concepts. You can absolutely cruise without ever paying extra for specialty dining. But if trying different restaurants is an important part of your vacation, it’s worth considering those costs when comparing your options.

Entertainment and Activities

A surprising amount of onboard entertainment is included in your cruise fare. Depending on the ship, that may include live music, theater productions, comedy shows, trivia, game shows, deck parties and other scheduled entertainment.

You’ll also generally have access to pools, hot tubs, fitness centers and many of the ship’s public spaces. Some ships have additional attractions or experiences that carry a fee, so it’s always worth checking what’s included on the particular ship you’re considering.

So What’s Usually NOT Included?

This is where first-time cruisers can get caught off guard. While every cruise line structures its fares differently, some common additional expenses can include:

• Alcoholic beverages and some specialty drinks
• Wi-Fi
• Specialty dining
• Shore excursions
• Spa treatments
• Casino play
• Shopping
• Certain onboard activities or experiences
• Gratuities or service charges
• Transportation to and from the cruise port
• Airfare and pre- or post-cruise hotels

You certainly don’t need all of these things to enjoy your cruise. But you also don’t want to book based on the cruise fare alone and discover later that several things you assumed were included aren’t.

What About Drinks?

Basic beverages are typically available without an additional charge, although exactly what’s included varies by cruise line. Alcohol, specialty coffees, bottled water, sodas and other beverages may cost extra depending on the cruise line and fare you’ve selected.

That’s why you’ll see cruise lines offering beverage packages or fares that bundle drinks with other amenities. Whether a drink package is worth paying for is an entirely different conversation, and one we’ll tackle separately.

Don’t Forget Gratuities

Gratuities are another expense that can surprise new cruisers.

Many cruise lines charge a recommended daily gratuity or service charge for each guest. Depending on the cruise line and fare you’ve booked, those gratuities may be added to your onboard account, prepaid before sailing or included as part of a package or promotion.

It’s something I always recommend factoring into your vacation budget rather than treating it as an unexpected expense once you’re onboard.

The Advertised Fare Isn’t the Whole Story

This is probably the most important thing to understand when comparing cruises.

The least expensive cruise fare isn’t necessarily the least expensive vacation.

Suppose one cruise appears to cost less than another. Once you add the drinks you want, Wi-Fi, specialty dining or other extras, the difference between the two may become much smaller. Another fare may look more expensive initially but include several things you would have purchased anyway. That doesn’t automatically make the more expensive fare the better choice either. The better question is:

What will I actually use?

If you rarely drink alcohol, don’t care about Wi-Fi and are perfectly happy eating at the included restaurants, paying for a bundle of extras may make no sense for you. If you know you’ll want those things, however, comparing the total value rather than the starting fare can give you a much better picture of what your vacation will really cost.

Cruise Fare vs. Total Vacation Cost

There’s one more distinction I think is important when planning a cruise. Your cruise fare and your total vacation cost are not the same thing.

You’ll also want to think about expenses such as airfare, a hotel before your cruise, transportation to the port, travel insurance and shore excursions. And depending on the destination, those expenses can be significant.

Building those costs into the plan from the beginning makes it much easier to choose a cruise that comfortably fits your overall travel budget.

Compare What’s Included, Not Just the Price

Cruise pricing can look complicated at first, especially when you’re comparing different cruise lines, ships, promotions and fare packages. You don’t need to memorize every inclusion before you start looking. Instead, when comparing cruises, ask yourself:

What is included in this particular fare, what will I want to add and what will my vacation realistically cost once I do?

That’s a much better way to compare two cruises than simply choosing whichever one has the lowest number on the screen. Because the goal isn’t necessarily to find the cheapest cruise. It’s to find the cruise that gives you the right experience and the best value for the way you want to travel.

Thinking About Your Next Cruise?

You don’t have to sort through every cruise line, itinerary and fare option on your own. I can help you narrow down the choices and find a cruise that fits the way you want to travel.

Voyage with Amy
Expertly Planned. Personally Crafted.

When people start looking for a cruise, it’s easy to begin with the cruise line. Maybe you’ve sailed with one before and enjoyed it, or you’ve seen photos of a new ship that looks incredible. You might even start by comparing prices and seeing which cruise catches your attention.

But when I think about planning a cruise, I prefer to start somewhere else.

Where do you want to go?

Maybe Alaska has been on your travel list for years. You want to experience the glaciers, see wildlife and visit some of the small towns along the coast. Maybe you’ve always wanted to explore the Mediterranean and like the idea of waking up somewhere different each morning. Or perhaps you’re dreaming about warm Caribbean beaches and simply want an easy vacation somewhere beautiful.

Once you know what you want to experience, you can start looking at the cruise itineraries that will actually take you there. From there, it becomes much easier to determine which cruise line, ship and cabin make the most sense for your trip.

Because as important as the ship can be, where it takes you matters too.

Start With the Destination, Not the Cruise Line

There are certainly times when the ship itself is a big part of the reason for taking a cruise. Some travelers want to experience a particular new ship or spend their vacation enjoying everything onboard. But if your reason for cruising is to experience a destination, I think the destination should lead the planning process. Instead of deciding you want to sail with a particular cruise line and then choosing from the itineraries it offers, start by identifying the places you most want to see. Once you know that, you can compare the cruise lines and ships sailing those itineraries. This can open up possibilities you might not have considered otherwise.

The cruise line you sailed with last time may still turn out to be the best fit. But another cruise line might offer an itinerary with a port you really want to visit, more time in a particular destination or a scenic cruising experience that is important to you. The goal isn’t to choose a cruise line first and make the vacation fit around it. It’s to find the cruise that fits the vacation you actually want.

Look Beyond the Number of Ports

When comparing two cruises, it’s tempting to count the stops. One itinerary visits three ports. Another visits four. Four must be better, right?

Not necessarily.

The number of ports only tells you how many places the ship visits. It doesn’t tell you much about what those days will actually look like. Look at which ports are included rather than simply how many there are. If one itinerary includes a destination that is especially important to you, that may be more valuable than an additional stop somewhere you aren’t particularly excited about visiting.

The balance between port days and sea days matters too.

A port-intensive itinerary can be wonderful when your goal is to see as much of a destination as possible, but several early mornings and full days of sightseeing in a row can also make for a busy vacation. An itinerary with an extra sea day gives you more time to enjoy the ship and slow down between destinations. Neither is automatically better. They simply create different kinds of vacations.

Pay Attention to How Long You’ll Actually Be in Port

Seeing a destination listed on an itinerary is only the beginning. The arrival and departure times can make a significant difference. A ship that arrives early in the morning and stays until evening gives you a very different opportunity to explore than one that arrives around midday and leaves a few hours later.

This becomes particularly important if there is something specific you want to do ashore. You may have enough time for a walking tour and lunch on a shorter port day, while a longer stay could give you time to venture farther from the port or choose a more involved excursion.

Occasionally, itineraries include an overnight stay in port, which can create an entirely different experience by giving you additional time ashore without needing to return to the ship until the following day. So when comparing itineraries, don’t stop at the port names. Look at the clock too.

Scenic Cruising Counts as Part of the Itinerary

Not every memorable destination requires you to step off the ship. This is especially true in places like Alaska, where scenic cruising can be one of the highlights of the entire vacation. Sailing through areas surrounded by mountains, glaciers and wildlife is part of the destination experience even though it isn’t technically a port stop. That means two Alaska itineraries that appear similar at first glance may offer different experiences once you look more closely at their scenic cruising routes. It is another reason I prefer to compare the complete itinerary rather than simply looking at the departure port, number of nights and list of stops.

And it may even affect another decision you make later: your cabin.

On a cruise where much of the scenery can be enjoyed from the ship, having your own balcony may be more important to you than it would be on another vacation. On a port-intensive itinerary where you expect to spend very little time in your room, you might decide you’d rather put that money toward excursions instead. The itinerary can help determine the cabin, rather than the other way around.

Sea Days Are Part of Your Vacation Too

Sea days sometimes look like blank spaces on an itinerary, but they shouldn’t be overlooked. They are your opportunity to enjoy the ship. Depending on the cruise, that could mean spending time by the pool, trying restaurants you haven’t visited yet, attending activities or entertainment, finding a quiet place to read or simply doing very little.

How many sea days you want depends on the kind of vacation you’re imagining. If the destination is your primary focus, you may prefer an itinerary with more ports and fewer days at sea. If you want the ship to be part of the vacation, a few sea days may be exactly what you want.

This is also where the particular ship begins to matter more. If an itinerary includes several sea days, I would pay closer attention to what the ship offers and whether those onboard experiences appeal to you.

Consider How You’ll Get Ashore

Another detail that can be easy to miss is how you actually get from the ship to the destination. At many ports, the ship docks and you simply walk ashore. At others, the ship may anchor offshore and passengers travel to land on smaller tender boats. Tendering isn’t necessarily a reason to avoid an itinerary, but it can affect how quickly you get ashore and how you plan your day.

The location of the cruise port itself matters too. Sometimes the destination named on the itinerary is close to the attractions you want to see. In other places, reaching the city or sightseeing area may require additional transportation, which can take time out of your day ashore.. These aren’t necessarily dealbreakers. They’re simply part of understanding what you’re actually choosing when you compare itineraries.

Don’t Forget About the Embarkation Port

Your cruise vacation doesn’t necessarily begin when you step onto the ship. Where the cruise departs from can affect airfare, hotel costs and the overall logistics of your trip. And sometimes the embarkation city is worth turning into part of the vacation itself.

If you’re flying to your cruise, I generally think of the pre-cruise stay as part of the overall travel plan rather than something completely separate. Arriving at least a day before embarkation gives you a buffer in case of flight delays or other travel disruptions, and it may also give you an opportunity to experience another destination along the way.This is especially worth considering when comparing itineraries that depart from different ports. A cruise fare may look better on one sailing, but airfare and pre-cruise expenses could change the total cost of the vacation.

The Ship Still Matters

Starting with the destination doesn’t mean the cruise line or ship isn’t important. Once you’ve identified the itineraries that take you where you want to go, then you can start comparing the ships that sail them. This is where the questions from my blog post about choosing the right cruise line become useful.

Do you want a lively ship with lots of activities and entertainment? Would you prefer something quieter and more relaxed? Are you traveling with children or multiple generations? How important are dining, entertainment and onboard amenities?

You may find several cruise lines offering similar itineraries. At that point, the experience onboard can help narrow the choices. And sometimes there will be a tradeoff. Your favorite itinerary might be on a ship that wasn’t originally at the top of your list, while the ship you’re most excited about might skip a destination you really wanted to visit. That’s where your priorities come into play.

Compare the Whole Vacation

Cruise itineraries aren’t just a list of ports. They’re the framework for your entire vacation. The destinations, time in port, sea days, scenic cruising, embarkation city and ship all work together to create the experience.

Price matters too, of course, but just as I don’t think the lowest cruise fare always represents the best value, I don’t think the itinerary with the most ports is automatically the best choice. I would rather look at what you’re getting from the vacation as a whole. If one cruise costs a little more but visits the destination you’ve always wanted to see, gives you more time ashore or includes an experience that’s important to you, that difference may be worthwhile.

On the other hand, if your goal is primarily to relax and enjoy the ship, paying more for a port-intensive itinerary you don’t particularly care about may not make sense.

Start With Where You Want to Go

There are a lot of decisions involved in choosing a cruise, but you don’t have to make all of them at once. Start with the simplest question:

Where do you want to go?

Then we can look at the itineraries that will take you there and compare the details that could make one a better fit than another. Once we understand the trip you’re trying to create, we can determine which cruise line and ship fit your travel style, which cabin makes sense and where your vacation budget is best spent.

That’s one of the things I enjoy most about cruise planning. There isn’t one cruise that’s right for everyone. The goal is to put the pieces together in a way that creates the right cruise for you.

Where Do You Want to Go Next?

Choosing the right itinerary starts with thinking about the kind of trip you want to experience. I can help you sort through the options and find a cruise that fits the way you want to travel.

Voyage with Amy
Expertly Planned. Personally Crafted.

Once you’ve chosen a cruise, the next decision can feel surprisingly complicated: Which cabin should you book?

At first, the choices seem pretty straightforward. Inside, oceanview, balcony or suite. Then you start looking at the actual booking options and suddenly there are multiple versions of each, different decks, obstructed views, guarantee cabins and category codes that don’t mean much unless you know what you’re looking at.

The good news is that you don’t need to understand every cabin category a cruise line offers. You just need to figure out what matters most for your trip.

How much time do you expect to spend in your cabin? Is having a view important to you? Would you rather spend more on your room or save that money for excursions and other experiences? Even the itinerary can influence which cabin makes the most sense.

Let’s start with the four main types you’ll encounter.

Inside Cabins

Inside cabins are typically the most affordable rooms on a cruise ship. They don’t have a window or balcony, but you’ll still have the basics you need, including a bed, private bathroom and storage.

For travelers who plan to spend most of their time exploring the ship or enjoying the ports, an inside cabin can be a smart way to keep the overall cost of the trip down. If you think of your cabin primarily as a place to sleep, shower and get ready for the day, you may not need to pay for a view you’re rarely there to enjoy.

There is another perk that some inside-cabin fans love: they can get very dark at night. Without sunlight coming through a window in the morning, sleeping in can be surprisingly easy.

The tradeoff, of course, is that you won’t have natural light or an outside view. Some people barely notice. Others quickly discover that seeing daylight from their cabin is an important part of enjoying the cruise.

Oceanview Cabins

Oceanview cabins offer a window or porthole that lets in natural light and gives you a view of the water. The window doesn’t open, but it can make the room feel brighter and provide a connection to what’s happening outside.

An oceanview can be a nice middle ground for someone who doesn’t necessarily need private outdoor space but doesn’t want an interior room either. Depending on the ship and sailing, the price difference between an inside and oceanview cabin may also be relatively small.

One thing to pay attention to is the type of view. Not every oceanview cabin offers the same experience. Windows can vary in size and placement, and some cabins may have partially or fully obstructed views because of lifeboats or other ship structures.

That doesn’t automatically make an obstructed-view cabin a bad choice. If the price is right and your main goal is simply having natural light, it may be a great value. You just want to know what you’re booking before you get onboard.

Balcony Cabins

Balcony cabins are one of the most popular choices, and it’s easy to understand why. In addition to the cabin itself, you have your own outdoor space where you can step outside, watch the ocean and enjoy the scenery without leaving your room. For some itineraries, that can be especially appealing. On a scenic cruise, waking up and stepping onto your balcony to see the landscape outside can become part of the experience itself.

A balcony can also be nice if you enjoy having a little quiet time away from the busier areas of the ship. You can sit outside in the morning, watch the ship sail into port or simply enjoy the ocean for a while without searching for a chair on an open deck.

But a balcony isn’t automatically worth the extra money for everyone. If you’re taking a port-intensive cruise and expect to spend very little time in your cabin, you might decide you’d rather put that money toward excursions, specialty dining or another part of the trip.

And just like oceanview cabins, not all balconies are the same. Balcony size, configuration and view can vary, and some may be partially obstructed. It’s worth looking at the specific cabin rather than assuming every balcony within a category will be identical.

Suites and Larger Cabin Categories

Suites can vary significantly from one cruise line and ship to another. Some are essentially larger versions of a balcony cabin, while others offer separate living and sleeping spaces, larger balconies and additional amenities. Depending on the cruise line, booking certain suites may also come with benefits such as priority boarding, dedicated dining areas or access to private lounges and other exclusive spaces.

For families and groups, larger cabin categories can sometimes solve another problem: space. While many standard cruise cabins can accommodate more than two people, being able to sleep four people in a cabin doesn’t necessarily mean four people will be comfortable sharing it for a week. This is one area where it’s worth comparing your options carefully. Sometimes a suite makes sense. In other situations, booking two cabins may provide more space, privacy and even an additional bathroom for a similar price.

What About Guarantee Cabins?

You may also see a guarantee cabin offered when you’re comparing fares.

With a guarantee, you’re booking a particular cabin category or minimum level, but you’re allowing the cruise line to assign your specific cabin. That can sometimes result in a lower fare, but you’re giving up control over exactly where you’ll be located. You could end up with a cabin you’re perfectly happy with. You might even receive a higher category than the minimum you booked. But you could also be assigned a location you wouldn’t have selected yourself.

If you don’t care much about cabin location and the savings are worthwhile, a guarantee can be a good option. If you know you’re sensitive to noise, concerned about motion or simply want to know exactly where you’ll be staying, choosing your own cabin may be worth paying a little more.

Why Are There So Many Categories Within Each Cabin Type?

This is where cruise cabin shopping can become confusing. You may find several balcony categories that appear almost identical or multiple interior categories with different prices. Cruise lines use these subcategories to distinguish things such as location, deck and sometimes cabin features or included benefits.

A higher category doesn’t necessarily mean the room itself is dramatically different. Sometimes you’re paying more because of where the cabin is located on the ship rather than what’s inside it. That’s why I wouldn’t choose a cabin based on the category name or price alone. Once you’ve decided which general cabin type you want, it’s worth looking at the actual location and details of the specific rooms available.

We’ll go much deeper into that in another article because cabin location deserves a conversation of its own.

How Much Should You Spend on Your Cabin?

There isn’t a percentage or formula that works for everyone. Instead, think about what you’re giving up to move into the next cabin category. If upgrading from an inside to a balcony adds $1,000 to your trip, what else could you do with that $1,000? Maybe you’d rather book an incredible excursion or extend your vacation with an extra night or two before the cruise.

On the other hand, if the difference is relatively small and you know you’ll use the balcony every day, the upgrade may be an easy decision.

The itinerary matters too. You may make a completely different cabin choice for a short Caribbean getaway than you would for a scenic Alaska cruise. That’s why I don’t think there is one cabin category everyone should always book.

Choosing the Cabin That’s Right for You

Before booking, think about how you actually travel. If you’re rarely in your room on vacation, an inside or oceanview cabin might give you everything you need while leaving more room in the budget for experiences. If having private outdoor space is part of what you’re imagining when you picture your cruise, a balcony may be money well spent. And if you’re traveling with family, need more space or want additional amenities, it may be worth comparing suites and larger cabin options rather than simply squeezing everyone into a standard room.

Most importantly, don’t assume that two cabins with the same general description are necessarily equal. Once you decide on the type of cabin you want, take a closer look at the specific cabin before you book it. Because choosing your cruise cabin isn’t about finding the most expensive room you can afford. It’s about deciding which parts of the cabin experience are worth paying for on this particular trip.

That answer may change from one cruise to the next. And that’s exactly why choosing the right cabin is part of planning the right cruise.

Not Sure Which Cabin to Choose?

The right cabin can look different for every traveler and every trip. I can help you compare your options and choose a cabin that fits your priorities and budget.

Voyage with Amy
Expertly Planned. Personally Crafted.

If you’ve decided you want to take a cruise, one of the first questions you’ll probably run into is also one of the biggest: Which cruise line should I choose?

It’s easy to assume that cruise lines are mostly interchangeable. Pick an itinerary, find a ship and book a cabin. But the cruise line you choose can have just as much impact on your vacation as the destination itself.

Some cruise lines are lively and casual. Others lean toward a quieter, more traditional cruise experience. You’ll find ships built around family activities, ships known for dining and entertainment and others where the destination is much more of the focus. The best cruise line isn’t necessarily the one with the newest ship or the lowest fare. It’s the one that fits the way you like to travel.

Start With the Kind of Vacation You Actually Enjoy

Before comparing ships or prices, think about what makes a vacation feel like a vacation to you. Do you like having plenty to do from morning until night, or do you want time to relax without feeling like you’re missing something? Maybe great meals are a big part of the experience for you, or perhaps live entertainment is something you look forward to when you travel.

Who you’re traveling with matters too. A couple looking for a relaxing getaway may have very different priorities from a family traveling with children or several generations vacationing together. Maybe the ship itself is part of the adventure, or maybe you’re choosing a cruise because you want an easy way to experience several destinations in one trip.

There isn’t a right answer. Your answers simply help narrow down which cruise lines deserve a closer look.

If You Want a Fun, Casual Atmosphere

Some travelers want their cruise to feel easygoing from the minute they step onboard, with pool decks, casual dining, comedy shows, live music and plenty happening throughout the day.

Cruise lines such as Carnival are well known for this kind of vacation. Carnival can also be a great option when value matters, particularly for families and groups traveling together. The atmosphere tends to be relaxed rather than formal, which appeals to travelers who don’t want to spend their vacation worrying about doing things a certain way.

If You Like Having Lots of Choices

Maybe your ideal vacation is less about following a schedule and more about deciding what sounds good in the moment. Norwegian Cruise Line built much of its identity around that idea. Its Freestyle Cruising concept emphasizes flexibility, including when and where you dine.

Norwegian ships typically offer a wide variety of restaurants, entertainment and onboard activities. Depending on the ship and itinerary, you might find everything from large-scale productions and comedy to go-karts and expansive observation lounges.

I’ve cruised with Norwegian several times, and one of the things I appreciate is having options. You can fill your day with activities or find a quiet place and do very little at all. That flexibility can be especially appealing when the people traveling together don’t necessarily have the same idea of what a perfect vacation day looks like.

If The Ship Is Part of the Destination

For some travelers, the ports are only half the reason to go. Lines such as Royal Caribbean have taken the idea of the ship as a destination to another level. On its larger ships, you can find water parks, surf simulators, climbing walls, entertainment venues and entire neighborhoods designed to feel like distinct areas of the ship.

That can make these ships especially appealing to families and multigenerational groups because everyone can find something different to do. It also means choosing the ship can be just as important as choosing the cruise line. The experience on one of a cruise line’s older or smaller ships can be quite different from what you’ll find on its newest ships, so it’s worth looking beyond the name on the side of the vessel.

If You Prefer a More Relaxed, Refined Experience

Not everyone wants a cruise packed with attractions. If your idea of vacation involves good food, comfortable surroundings and a somewhat quieter atmosphere, lines such as Princess Cruises, Celebrity Cruises or Holland America Line may be worth considering.

These lines generally offer a more traditional or refined cruise experience without necessarily moving into the luxury-cruise price range. They can also be particularly appealing on destination-focused itineraries such as Alaska, where scenic viewing and time in port may matter more to you than having a long list of onboard attractions.

If You’re Looking for Value

This is where comparing cruises gets a little more complicated because the lowest advertised cruise fare isn’t always the least expensive vacation. One cruise line may start with a lower fare but charge separately for things you’ll probably want, while another may offer a higher fare that includes drinks, Wi-Fi, specialty dining or other benefits.

This is why I prefer looking at the total vacation value rather than simply comparing the number shown on the first search screen. For example, MSC Cruises frequently catches travelers’ attention with competitive pricing, particularly on newer ships. Depending on the sailing and fare type, it can offer a lot of ship for the money. Norwegian’s packages can also change the value equation because certain extras may already be bundled into your fare.

Instead of only asking, Which cruise is cheapest? I think there’s a better question: What am I actually getting for the price?

Don’t Forget About the Itinerary

You can find the perfect ship and still choose the wrong cruise. If seeing Alaska is your priority, for example, the itinerary, time in port and scenic cruising opportunities may matter more than whether the ship has the newest attractions. The same is true in Europe, the Caribbean and other destinations.

Look beyond the number of nights and the departure port. Compare where the ship actually goes, how long you’ll be there and whether there are destinations that are especially important to you. Sometimes an itinerary with an additional port or a longer day ashore is worth paying a little more for, especially when the destination is one of the main reasons you’re taking the trip.

The People You’re Traveling With Matter Too

The cruise I would recommend for a couple celebrating an anniversary might be completely different from the one I’d suggest for grandparents traveling with their children and grandchildren. When you’re planning for a group, cabin availability, connecting or nearby rooms, dining arrangements and activities for different ages can become just as important as the cruise fare.

That’s one reason there really isn’t a universal “best cruise line.” There is only the cruise line that’s the best fit for this trip.

So, Which Cruise Line Should You Choose?

Start with your priorities before you start with the cruise line. Think about how you like to spend your vacation, who is traveling with you, where you want to go and what you want included in the price. From there, you can compare the cruise lines and ships that actually fit those priorities.

You may discover that the cruise line you originally had in mind is exactly right for you, or you might find that another one fits your travel style much better. And that’s part of what I love about planning cruises. There are so many possibilities, but you don’t have to sort through all of them yourself.

Voyage with Amy helps travelers compare cruise options based on the experience they’re actually looking for, taking into consideration the itinerary, ship, cabin and overall value. The goal isn’t simply to book a cruise. It’s to find the cruise that feels right for you.

Not Sure Which Cruise Line Is Right for You?

Every traveler and every trip is different. I can help you compare the options and find a cruise line that fits the experience you’re looking for.

Voyage with Amy
Expertly Planned. Personally Crafted.

Welcome Aboard

At Voyage With Amy, travel planning is personal. Every cruise vacation should reflect your pace, priorities, and style, whether you are dreaming of glacier views in Alaska, sun-soaked Caribbean ports, charming river towns in Europe, or the coastal beauty of Canada and New England.

Working with a travel advisor means you do not have to sort through endless ship options, cabin categories, itineraries, and fine print on your own. Instead, you get thoughtful guidance designed to help you choose a cruise that feels effortless from the moment you start planning.

What Personalized Planning Includes

• Matching you with the right cruise line, ship, and itinerary
• Helping you compare destinations, travel seasons, and onboard experiences
• Advising on cabin choices, dining preferences, and travel style
• Creating a smoother planning process with expert support along the way

More Than Booking a Cruise

A great cruise is not just about where the ship goes. It is about how the entire experience fits you. Some travelers want a relaxed escape with plenty of sea days, while others want immersive port experiences, cultural discovery, or a celebration-worthy itinerary with elevated touches.

The best cruise is not simply the most popular one. It is the one that feels designed for you.

That is where Voyage With Amy comes in. With a warm, refined approach and a focus on personalized service, Amy helps travelers narrow the options and feel confident in every decision, from destination selection to the final details that make a trip feel seamless.

Destinations to Inspire Your Next Voyage

• Alaska for dramatic scenery, wildlife, and unforgettable natural beauty
• The Caribbean for sunshine, easygoing luxury, and island variety
• Canada & New England for coastal charm, history, and seasonal color
• The Mediterranean for culture, cuisine, and iconic ports
• The British Isles for storybook landscapes and rich heritage
• River cruises for intimate ships, scenic sailing, and immersive experiences

Start with Expert Guidance

If you are ready to plan a cruise vacation that feels thoughtful, polished, and truly tailored to you, Voyage With Amy is here to help. Personalized planning takes the guesswork out of the process so you can focus on the excitement of where you are going next.

When you are ready, Plan My Trip and start designing a voyage that fits you beautifully.

Voyage with Amy
Expertly Planned. Personally Crafted.